
Navigating Schisms in the Objectivist Movement
https://bit.ly/arischisms
In this episode of New Ideal Live, Harry Binswanger, Onkar Ghate and Elan Journo discuss why schisms occur within intellectual movements, and the principles that guide the Ayn Rand Institute in navigating schisms within the Objectivist movement.
Among the topics covered:
● Background on ARI’s new essay on schisms in the Objectivist movement;
● Ayn Rand’s view of the necessity of moral judgment;
● The role of proportionality in moral judgment;
● Why ARI is publicly stating the principles it uses to navigate conflicts;
● Why disagreement is a normal feature of all intellectual movements;
● Why disagreement is to be expected even in the Objectivist movement;
● Schisms in other positive intellectual movements;
● Why ignoring disagreement is not justified in a “war of ideas”;
● Why schisms clarify issues fundamental to intellectual movements;
● The philosophic disagreement at the root of the dispute with David Kelley;
● Why ARI vets the moral and intellectual integrity of those who speak on its behalf;
● The importance of withdrawing one’s moral sanction from evil;
● Why objectivity requires distinguishing between public and private information;
● Why arbitrary claims cannot be evaluated and must be dismissed;
● How to evaluate public allegations made about private events;
● Whether outsiders must take a side on a private dispute made public;
● Why the “court of public opinion” has no mechanism for evaluating the objectivity of testimony.
Mentioned in the discussion are the essays “Of Schisms, Public and Private” by Ghate and Binswanger, and “Fact and Value” by Leonard Peikoff.
The podcast was recorded on March 9, 2022.
Note: This video has been edited from its original livestream.
0:00:00 ARI's new essay on schisms
0:01:58 Ayn Rand on moral judgment
0:04:30 Proportionality in moral judgment
0:07:43 A public statement of principles
0:12:56 Disagreement is normal
0:15:24 Disagreement within the Objectivist movement
0:19:12 Schisms in other positive movements
0:24:25 The danger of Ignoring disagreements
0:28:12 How schisms clarify issues
0:32:42 The Kelley dispute
0:36:07 ARI judges its spokespersons
0:43:41 Refusing to sanction evil
0:50:20 Public vs. private information
0:56:50 Arbitrary claims
1:02:05 Public claims about private events
1:11:13 Must outsiders take a stand?
1:15:25 The "court of public opinion"
Subscribe to ARI’s YouTube channel to make sure you never miss a video:
https://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=AynRandInstitute
Download or stream free courses on Ayn Rand’s works and ideas with the Ayn Rand University app:
– App Store https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/ayn-rand-university/id1452535178?mt=8
– Google Play https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.aynrandu
ARI is funded by donor contributions. You can support our work by becoming an ARI Member or making a one-time contribution: https://ari.aynrand.org/donate
******
Keep in Touch! Sign up to receive email updates from ARI: https://aynrand.org/signup
Follow ARI on Twitter: https://twitter.com/AynRandInst
Follow ARI on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AynRandInstitute
Follow ARI on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/aynrandorg
Subscribe to the ARI Live! podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ayn-rand-institute-live/id1440399458
******
Explore these ideas further! ARI's online publication, New Ideal, explores pressing cultural issues from the perspective of Ayn Rand’s philosophy, Objectivism: https://newideal.aynrand.org/
Join an upcoming virtual or in-person event: https://ari.aynrand.org/events/
Visit ARI’s website for more about our content and programs: https://ari.aynrand.org/
Onkar Ghate is the chief philosophy officer and a senior fellow at the Ayn Rand Institute.
