
"You Can't Force People To Think"
Here's a transcript of this short conversation between Dave Rubin and Steve Simpson on the (im)practicality of "hate speech" laws:
Dave Rubin: Letting someone speak even if you don’t like their ideas. And then letting logic and reason dictate the answer.
Steve Simpson: Yeah, definitely. And that’s absolutely essential to have a free society. It’s absolutely essential to allow people the freedom to reach their own conclusions, true or not. But the way you asked the question, I think was interesting. It’s, have they ever worked? Have hate speech laws or restricting thought, or speech, ever worked? And my answer to that is “Well, it really depends on what you mean by worked.” So, in one sense: Yeah, they have worked. They’ve worked to enslave entire societies. I mean, if we look at totalitarianism, they control thought because they need to control action and they need to control what everybody does. So the first thing they do is censor, the first thing they do is control what people can think. Now, if you look at it from the standpoint of a free society – what we have now both in America and Europe is very much a mixture of freedom and controls – but you can’t ever succeed in that way. You cannot succeed to keep bad ideas down by outlawing them. In fact, all you end up doing is you drive them beneath the surface, and you cause the very hate and resentment that you’re trying to prevent. And the reason for that is you can’t force people to think. It’s just not possible. You can enslave them, but you just cannot force them to agree with you.
The panelists are Steve Simpson, director of Legal Studies at the Ayn Rand Institute and editor of "Defending Free Speech"; Flemming Rose, author of "Tyranny of Silence: How One Cartoon Ignited a Global Debate on the Future of Free Speech," and Dave Rubin, creator and host of the Rubin Report. The event, "Free Speech Under Attack," took place at Objectivist Summer Conference 2017 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, on Tuesday, June 13, 2017.
BUY “DEFENDING FREE SPEECH” ON AMAZON
https://www.amazon.com/Defending-Free-Speech-Steve-Simpson/dp/0979466180
SUBSCRIBE TO ARI’S YOUTUBE CHANNEL
https://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=AynRandInstitute
ABOUT THE AYN RAND INSTITUTE
ARI offers educational experiences, based on Ayn Rand's books and ideas, to a variety of audiences, including students, educators, policymakers and lifelong learners. ARI also engages in research and advocacy efforts, applying Rand's ideas to current issues and seeking to promote her philosophical principles of reason, rational self-interest and laissez-faire capitalism. We invite you to explore how Ayn Rand viewed the world — and to consider the distinctive insights offered by ARI's experts today.
SUPPORT ARI WITH A DONATION
https://ari.aynrand.org/donate/creditcard
EXPLORE ARI
http://www.AynRand.org
FOLLOW ARI ON TWITTER
https://twitter.com/AynRandInst
LIKE ARI ON FACEBOOK
https://www.facebook.com/AynRandInstitute
EXPLORE ARI CAMPUS
https://campus.aynrand.org/
INFORMATION ABOUT OBJECTIVIST SUMMER CONFERENCES
http://objectivistconferences.com/
LEARN ABOUT AYN RAND STUDENT CONFERENCES
http://aynrandcon.org/
Steve Simpson is a constitutional lawyer who served as director of Legal Studies and senior editor at the Ayn Rand Institute (2013–2018).