
How America’s 9/11 Response Destroyed Trust in Institutions
In this episode of New Ideal Live, Onkar Ghate and Elan Journo discuss America’s failed response to 9/11 and some of its consequences, including the discrediting of American political and intellectual institutions, the proliferation of conspiracy fantasies, and the rise of “populism.”
Among the topics covered:
● Why 9/11 was a turning point in American foreign policy and in the wider culture;
● How ARI’s analysis of 9/11 and America’s military response differs from mainstream analyses;
● Government institutions’ evasion of the nature of the Islamic totalitarianism movement that caused 9/11;
● How this evasion led to the deaths of American troops deployed to help create new Middle Eastern governments that empowered Islamists;
● How the evasive response to 9/11 discredited political institutions, the media, and the universities in the eyes of many Americans;
● How the post-9/11 climate of evasion mainstreamed conspiracy fantasies and unjustified skepticism of America’s military capabilities;
● How the 2008 financial crisis and subsequent bailouts further discredited the government, the media, and the universities;
● How the “populist” view of “elites” as the enemy was fueled by the financial crisis and the handling of the Covid-19 pandemic;
● Why the root of the problem is the failure to uphold America’s founding ideals.
Mentioned in this podcast are Journo’s article “Carter, Reagan, Bush and Clinton Paved the Road to 9/11” and the book Failing to Confront Islamic Totalitarianism, edited by Ghate and Journo.
The podcast was recorded on September 7, 2022.
0:00:00 Introduction
0:00:32 9/11 as a turning point
0:04:43 ARI's analysis of 9/11
0:12:03 US government's response
0:22:28 Deaths of American troops
0:26:34 Discredited political institutions
0:36:14 Conspiracy fantasies
0:47:57 2008 financial crisis
0:54:40 Populist view of elites
1:01:12 Failing to uphold America's ideals
Onkar Ghate is the chief philosophy officer and a senior fellow at the Ayn Rand Institute.
