
The Real Meaning of 9/11
In this special joint episode of New Ideal Live and The Yaron Brook Show, Onkar Ghate and Elan Journo join Yaron Brook to discuss the key events and turning points since 9/11, and provide a retrospective on ARI’s philosophic analysis of U.S. policy.
Among the topics covered:
• Recalling the day of the attacks and the immediate aftermath;
• The foreign policy failures that enabled the terrorist attacks;
• The pragmatism that prevented the U.S. from identifying the ideological nature of the enemy’s threat;
• The leftist/libertarian claim that the attacks were America’s own fault;
• ARI’s take on the weak American response to the 9/11 attacks;
• State sponsorship (by Iran, etc.) of the Islamic totalitarian movement;
• What a morally principled response to the attacks would have looked like;
• The difference between war and law enforcement;
• The anti-intellectual, tribalist nature of 9/11 conspiracism;
• Whether it’s true that we’ve surrendered freedom for security;
• Whether the U.S. should recognize or send aid to the Taliban;
• Resources on the history of Iran
• Whether America should fight Islamic totalitarianism everywhere;
• How history would have been different if America had pursued the right strategy;
• Whether America has become an easy target for Islamist terrorism;
• How the Taliban contributed to the 9/11 terrorist attacks;
• How altruist morality corrupts our thinking about hostage situations;
• Whether another American historical figure would have responded better to 9/11;
• The right’s infatuation with the Taliban;
• Saudi Arabia’s support of terrorism, and how America should have dealt with it;
• How the U.S. could have thwarted the attack or defeated the attackers’ state sponsors.
Mentioned in the discussion are Leonard Peikoff’s article “End States Who Sponsor Terrorism,” (https://peikoff.com/essays_and_articles/end-states-who-sponsor-terrorism/) his talk “America vs. Americans” (https://courses.aynrand.org/campus-courses/leonard-peikoff-at-the-ford-hall-forum/america-vs-americans/) and the book Failing to Confront Islamic Totalitarianism, edited by Elan Journo and Onkar Ghate. (https://newideal.aynrand.org/new-ari-book-examines-what-went-wrong-after-9-11/?utm_source=podcast&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=2021-08-16)
0:00:00 Introduction
0:02:07 The day of the attacks
0:20:07 Foreign policy failures
0:32:05 How pragmatism blinded U.S. policy
0:41:25 Were the attacks America's fault?
0:58:28 The weak American response
1:10:34 State sponsorship of Islamism
1:18:09 A morally principled response
1:39:52 War vs. law enforcement
1:43:50 9/11 conspiracism
1:54:10 Have we surrendered freedom for security?
1:58:25 Recognition of, aid to the Taliban
2:00:02 History of Iran
2:01:13 Fighting Islamic totalitarianism elsewhere
2:04:08 History of Iran
2:05:47 What if America had responded properly?
2:21:32 Is America an easy target now?
2:25:00 How Taliban contributed to 9/11 attacks
2:27:08 Altruist morality and hostage situations
2:28:32 Who would have responded better?
2:29:27 The right's infatuation with Taliban
2:32:00 Saudi Arabias support of terrorism
2:35:18 What the U.S. could have done
Elan Journo writes and speaks for ARI on foreign policy issues.
