
The Sorry Legacy of Our Policy Toward Iran
On August 12, author Salman Rushdie, who’s had an Iranian fatwa against him for over 30 years, was brutally stabbed during an event in New York. Last month, Masih Alinejad, a journalist and activist persecuted by the Iranian regime, was saved from an assassin lurking outside her house, also in New York—a year after a kidnapping attempt against her was foiled. Threats against John Bolton and other U.S. officials have also recently been prevented.
What explains Iran’s targeting of individuals for assassination, even on U.S soil? How should the U.S. in particular, and the West in general, act towards Iran? What is the philosophical nature of the Iranian regime? Join Onkar Ghate, Nikos Sotirakopoulos and Agustina Vergara Cid to discuss the implications of recent and historical attacks and the philosophical principles needed to effectively oppose the regime and Islamic totalitarianism.
Among the topics covered:
● The history of Iran’s fatwa against Rushdie;
● Alinejad’s activism and Iranian agents’ attempts to kidnap and assassinate her;
● Iran’s attempt to assassinate Bolton following the killing of Qassem Soleimani;
● How U.S. foreign policy over the last several administrations emboldened Iran and other enemies;
● The amorality of President Joe Biden’s statement about the attack on Rushdie;
● America’s long history of appeasing Iran even in the face of acts of war against the U.S.;
● The power of fundamentalist Islam and the need to convince its adherents that this ideology cannot win;
● How the U.S. should have responded to Iran’s 1979 seizure of the U.S. embassy in Tehran;
● Why an alliance of evil regimes would be insignificant if the U.S. stood up for American values;
● What a proper U.S. response to Islamic totalitarianism would involve;
● How the intellectuals’ propagation of cultural relativism and hatred for America has led to widespread misunderstanding of regimes like Iran.
Mentioned in this podcast are Ghate and Elan Journo’s book Failing to Confront Islamic Totalitarianism and Leonard Peikoff’s essays “End States Who Sponsor Terrorism” and “Religious Terrorism vs. Free Speech.”
The podcast was recorded on August 17, 2022.
0:00:00 Introduction
0:01:12 Fatwa against Rushdie
0:06:31 Alinejad assassination plot
0:11:35 Bolton assassination plot
0:14:59 U.S. foreign policy on Iran
0:24:01 Biden's amoral Rushdie statement
0:28:34 U.S. appeasement of Iran
0:37:54 Power of fundamentalist Islam
0:44:51 1979 embassy hostage crisis
0:48:48 Standing up for American values
0:54:27 Opposing Islamic totalitarianism
1:01:43 Intellectuals' hatred of America
Onkar Ghate is the chief philosophy officer and a senior fellow at the Ayn Rand Institute.
